The annual horse trading at Wingecarribee Council is in full swing with the mayoral election to be held this Wednesday (September 17), and nary a concern for the public interest is in sight.
One year on from the election of the Abbott government and our local MPs are firmly ensconced in their new jobs.
Throsby’s Stephen Jones is now in his second term and rising through the Opposition ranks and is currently Assistant Shadow Minister for Health. Hume MP Angus Taylor, a first-termer replacing retired warhorse Alby Schultz, has taken up the campaign firmly against wind farms and the renewable energy target.
Meanwhile, the region’s state MPs are eyeing off the end-of-year before a sprint to the 2015 March state election.
Liberal Pru Goward will re-contest the seat of Goulburn, which has largely been redistributed away from the Southern Highlands but retains Moss Vale and the southern villages. She will not be challenged by Burrinjuck Nationals MP Katrina Hodgkinson, who will run in Cootamundra instead.
With the redistribution underway, Goward’s office is expected to be relocated to the city of Goulburn in coming months, leaving the Wingecarribee shire bereft of any local MP office for the first time in living memory (well, my living memory – yours might be longer).
At the election, Bowral, Mittagong and the northern villages will come under the seat of Wollondilly, presently occupied by Liberal Jai Rowell, currently Minister for Mental Health and Assistant Minister for Health. Rowell’s office is presently located in Tahmoor.
Labor’s candidate in Wollondilly is yet to be publicly announced but there should be some news on that front soon.
Fortunately, our local MPs have so far not raised the ire of the Independent Commission Against Corruption, whose current investigation has claimed more than a few scalps.
Here’s the scorecard for those playing along at home:
- seven MPs are now sitting on the cross-bench
- two resigned from Parliament
- one Premier resigned
- a minister stood down
- a Senator stood down from his ministerial role
Down the hill, Shellharbour MP Anna Watson this week avoided facing a pre-selection challenge after the matter was referred to the ALP head office.
A state government panel appointed to consider reform of local government in New South Wales has hosed down talk of amalgamation at Wingecarribee Shire Council.
Local Government Minister Don Page released the Independent Local Government Review Panel’s final report this week.
The report recommends a series of ‘Joint Organisations’ (JO) be established throughout the state to take responsibility for regional planning and advocacy and some service delivery. They would also take over the role of existing Regional Organisations of Councils (ROCs).
Wingecarribee would become the northeastern edge of a Tablelands JO that stretches inland to Young, while neighbouring councils Wollondilly and in the Illawarra would be part of other JOs.
The JOs are intended to have anchoring councils that contain regional centres, and these centres would attract the bulk of future development and growth. However, in the medium term, the Panel suggests non-metropolitan parts of Wollondilly could be merged with Wingecarribee.
The panel has proposed a series of amalgamations in the Sydney region and some in the Hunter. It also suggests some amalgamations take place to consolidate the regional centres. One such example is a merger between rural Palerang and urban Queanbeyan on the Australian Capital Territory border.
With the opening of the Moss Vale War Memorial Aquatic Centre at the weekend, Wingecarribee Shire now has the covered pool that has been debated and fought over for decades.
Council ought to be congratulated for finally getting one of these things built, even if there is still disagreement about it’s size and location. The fact is that the facility is now open and ready for use.
Over the years, a lot of proposals have come and gone. The largest of these to be funded by council would have been propped up by sales of disused public land across the shire, and was the subject of a plebiscite at the time of the 2008 council election.
It’s something we can be really proud of despite all the obstacles that came up.
The community deserves this and it makes you wonder why we hadn’t built it a long time ago.
Had the 2008 plan proceeded, a much larger leisure centre would have been opened sometime in 2009 or 2010.
In fairness, Clr Whipper did propose to cover Bowral or Moss Vale Pool in lieu of building a leisure centre, but somewhere along the way that morphed into a full redevelopment of Moss Vale Pool, and tearing out a 33m pool to replace it with a 25m one.
The motion is recorded in a 2008 blog post by Clr Jim Clark:
An amendment by Clr Larry Whipper to not proceed with the land sales nor continue with the Leisure centre and instead cover Bowral or Moss Vale Pool was hotly debated and lost.
So, Wingecarribee finally has its covered pool, and the vitriol and hatred can be put to bed at council, at least until Renwick and other developments at Mittagong are fully occupied and the residents there demand their own year-round swimming facility.
A little over a year into a new term, and calls have been growing for the Wingecarribee Shire Council to be sacked. Weekly, acrimonious relationships between councillors and staff, between councillors and councillors, and between councillors and failed candidates play out in public – the Southern Highland News and 2ST being the main bearers of bad news, but ABC Illawarra playing along as well.* But how did we get to this point so early in a new term, and is there any way forward?
Where it all started
With things like this, pinpointing a moment of commencement is always difficult and imprecise. You could go all the way back to the founding of local democracy in the Southern Highlands to find a reason, but I think we can find one of the sources of trouble in the the 2004-08 council term. In that term, council bet a large sum of money on toxic debt sold by the investment bank Lehman Brothers. The exact amount seems to be disputed to this day, and the amount lost is similarly obscured. But what we do know is that when Lehman went belly up, council’s investment went down. And here began the acrimony.
Since council was now broke, there was no way to fund a shiny new leisure centre than sell off some unused assets. Nick Campbell-Jones led this charge, but was roundly labelled with all sorts of unmentionable names by a massive field of candidates at the forthcoming election, including the now Deputy Mayor Larry Whipper. Whipper seemed hell-bent against a leisure centre at this point.
History records that a plebiscite at the 2008 council election rejected the plan to sell off public land to fund the leisure centre, seemingly burying the plan. Campbell-Jones left council, but Whipper was returned.
What happened next
During the 2008-12 term of council, Whipper reconsidered his animosity to the leisure centre proposal and came up with a couple of other ideas, including the current facility at Moss Vale and one at Bowral Pool. After some wrangling, the site at Moss Vale was decided upon. Along the way, a business consortium proposed to build a whiz-bang centre near the Wingecarribee River at the Bong Bong Common, but this was turned down.
During this period, distrust of council was building all along as various grand schemes were proposed and hosed down due to budgetary constraints (in which the Lehman brouhaha played a big role) and planning issues. Councillors who seemed to flip-flop on issues contributed to the suspicion.
As the 2008 election neared, the redevelopment of Moss Vale Pool was given the go-ahead. Whipper released a statement to the following effect:
“The estimated cost to build the Moss Vale Aquatic Centre remains around $8 million dollars inclusive of all construction and project management costs,” he said. “And the Construction Manager will be under strict instruction to bring the project in or even under budget.”
“Council has always acknowledged that this project would be funded through loans and the sale of some Council assets with the remainder to be funded from Council’s Infrastructure Recovery Strategy
Note the funding ‘through the sale of Council assets’, just don’t call them parks.
At the 2012 election, the Liberal ticket romped it home, bringing Juliet Arkwright and Holly Campbell on to council. In 2008, two Liberal councillors had also been elected, but one (David Stranger) was booted out of the party mid-term. Former Mayor Duncan Gair was also returned to council, drawing the largest single personal vote of any other councillor. Gair stood as an ungrouped independent.
Since then, the council has broken into a neat 5/4 factional split, as follows:
- The ‘Government': Juliet Arkwright (Mayor); Larry Whipper (Deputy Mayor); Holly Campbell; Jim Clark; John Uliana.
- The ‘Opposition': Garry Turland; Ian Scandrett; Graham McLaughlin; Duncan Gair.
There are presently a number of direct sources of friction.
- There is a question has become whether Gair’s large personal vote should outweigh the large Liberal vote.
- There is an ‘unholy alliance’ between Green-aligned or leaning councillors (Whipper and Clark) and Liberal-aligned or leaning councillors (Arkwright, Campbell and Uliana), which goes against the Labor-Independent alliance on the other side. This stands in stark contrast to federal and state politics, where the Libs eventually favour even Labor over the Greens.
- Prominent local Liberals say that councillors should not have party allegiances and that Mayor Arkwright was not endorsed by the local branches in any case.
- The General Manager was released from his contract by council recently, amidst public murmurings about a breakdown in the relationship between he and the Mayor and Deputy Mayor.
- Mayor Arkwright has alleged on ABC radio that Clr John Uliana is the victim of persistent bullying by other councillors.
- Mayor Arkwright also called Clr Ian Scandrett a bully during a council meeting.
- Dozens of code of conduct complaints have been made by councillors and others against councillors.
- In May, one councillor was accused of being verbally abusive and swearing about other councillors in public.
Where to now
The state government has attempted to intervene via the Division of Local Government a number of times. Most recently, mediators appointed by the Division found that issues between councillors are irreconcilable. The DLG has also said some behaviour is ‘indicative of dysfunction’.
Other options open to the state government if council cannot resolve its own issues are temporary suspensions of councillors or the entire council, or sacking them all and calling in administrators. Such actions were taken in cases of corruption in Wollongong and dysfunction in Shellharbour in recent years.
The forthcoming report by the Independent Local Government Review Panel may set out amalgamations or other changes to Wingecarribee’s structure, negating the need for immediate fixes.
*The author of this post is a casual journalist at ABC Illawarra.
Throsby Labor MP Stephen Jones has been promoted onto the Opposition’s front bench as Shadow Parliamentary Secretary for Regional Development and Infrastructure. This is an outer shadow ministry position, chosen at the discretion of new Labor leader Bill Shorten.
Mr Jones campaigned for Anthony Albanese, Mr Shorten’s competitor for the leadership role. Nonetheless, he has been awarded the position by Mr Shorten today as the rest of the frontbench makeup was finalised. Mr Jones will assist Shadow Infrastructure Minister Mr Albanese.
Mr Jones released a statement shortly after the appointment, saying he looks forward to taking the fight up to Prime Minister Tony Abbott:
I’m very pleased to be promoted to the role of Shadow Parliamentary Secretary for Regional Development and Infrastructure and thank Opposition Leader Bill Shorten for this great opportunity.
Coming from the Illawarra, I understand the challenges facing regional Australia and the important role that the government plays in investing in crucial infrastructure projects – especially those which the private sector cannot or will not build.
In the last three years I’ve worked to secure more than $400 million in funding for major regional projects like the Maldon Dombarton Rail Link, Illawarra Regional Innovation and Investment Fund, Steel Transformation Plan, Home of Soccer, Regional Livestock Exchange and the Southern Youth and Family Services Community Hub and Youth Foyer.
Prime Minister Abbott has stated that he wants to be known as the ‘Infrastructure Prime Minister’ so I’m looking forward to holding him to account on this. A good start would be to confirm funding for local infrastructure like the Mount Ousley upgrade, Maldon Dombarton and Home of Soccer.
As amalgamation talk continues to bubble away amongst the Highlands’ political watchers, it is worth remembering that the shire’s towns and villages have survived multiple amalgamations before and probably will do again.
The NSW Electoral Commission has announced the final determinations of the NSW redistribution. The new boundaries will take effect for state elections from the March 2015 election.
Changes to the Southern Highlands electorates of Goulburn and Wollondilly are largely in line with the proposals released earlier this year. As expected, Goulburn shifts to an east-west orientation and now includes only the southern portion of Wingecarribee Shire, including Moss Vale.
The electorate of Wollondilly absorbs the remainder of Wingecarribee, including Bowral, Mittagong and the northern villages. The electorate of Goulburn takes Robertson and surrounds from Kiama.
The changes mean that Wingecarribee residents will be split between two state MPs in Pru Goward (Goulburn) and Jai Rowell (Wollondilly), but Gareth Ward (Kiama) will no longer have any responsibility for residents of the shire. It is expected that the Goulburn electorate office will relocate from Bowral to the city of Goulburn ahead of the 2015 election. The Wollondilly electorate office is located in Tahmoor and will probably remain there.
The image below shows most of the re-shaped electorates of Goulburn and Wollondilly, and all of the Wingecarribee Shire. For detailed information, download the PDF maps of Goulburn and Wollondilly from the electoral commission. In the image below, you can see Wingecarribee Shire at the right with the thick blue electorate line going through it.
Wingecarribee Shire Council has placed proposed fees and charges on public exhibition until October 14.
Council adopted the schedule of charges at their 11 September meeting, and has been careful to point out that they are broadly in line with facilities at Goulburn, Picton and Kiama. Indeed, they are almost identical to the charges at Wollondilly Leisure Centre, as this extract from the council agenda [PDF] shows:
It is worth noting that the Wollondilly Leisure Centre includes access to an outdoor 50m pool during summer months in addition to the smaller indoor pools, whereas the Moss Vale facility has a 25m lap pool, so the facility isn’t wholly comparable.
More information about the proposed fees, and how you can make a submission, is available on Council’s website.
Taken from their Facebook pages, here are thank you messages from the various candidates of Hume and Throsby following the election.
Big thanks to the people of Throsby for again endorsing me as your federal member. I’m honoured to have the chance to represent this great region for another three years. Also to my incredible family, staff and team of volunteers – Thank you. None of this could have happened without your ongoing support.
I am humbled by yesterday’s result, and so grateful for the support of so many, many people. The work of a thousand people increased the Liberal primary vote in Hume – doubling Labor’s vote. I feel a great weight of responsibility to every single voter in Hume – Labor, Liberal or other. I pay tribute and give huge thanks to my friend and mentor, outgoing member Alby Schultz – who has served this electorate and region with distinction for a quarter of a century. It will be difficult to engender the affection and respect with which so many thousands of people hold Alby, and his wife Gloria. Thank you Alby and Glo.
Firstly, I’d like to thank all my supporters and helpers for not only yesterdays effort, but your efforts throughout my campaign. Your support has been overwhelming so thank you from the bottom of my heart. To everyone who sent letters and messages of support, thank you. To all who sent messages asking questions or making points that never received a response, my apologies for not getting back toyou.
To my fellow Nationals across Australia who won yesterday congratulations, I know that together we can get Australia back on track. To those of you, who like me, were not fortunate to have won, hold your heads high, you all did a fantastic job!
I wish to congratulate Stephen Jones on his win, and to all the other candidates who stood in Throsby, well done for a friendly and clean campaign, democracy was truly at work yesterday here in Throsby.
Until next time, always your friend
A HUGE THANK YOU to all our supporters and volunteers. It was a good ‘first time’ result and I’m humbled by the number of people that voted for us. Thank you. A new party has been born. Watch this space. GO PUP!!
Friends Romans and Countryman thanks for the support.It was a hard game we played.We will be better for the challange.To my main election day men , John and Jeff thanks for your time and effort. Best party day without having a drink I have enjoyed.Thanks again. I will be focusing for the near future on honouring my my Honouring my God and Supporting my Footy Team.To everyone involved in the political adventure fellow candidates ,family and friends thanks . Cheers Glenn
Not the result we wanted – across Australia and here in Hume – but this is democracy. I’ll probably have more to say about the election later, but for now I just want to say a big thank you:
– THANK YOU to all the wonderful volunteers who helped throughout the campaign, especially on polling day
– THANK YOU to all the friends who have supported me and my family over the past few months
– THANK YOU to all the Facebook supporters who have lifted my spirits with encouraging comments and advice
And THANK YOU to all the wonderful people in the country towns and villages across Hume who I have met and who have inspired me with your passion, loyalty and commitment to your community.
Thanks to you all, I’ll live to fight another day.
…Oh yeah, one more vote of THANK YOU to my trusty campaign ute who has served with distinction on the campaign trail but can now return to her former life as a ute only! You are the best ute in the world!
If you know some we’ve missed, let us know.